Supreme Court grants Republican emergency appeal on TV ad rates before midterms
- The Supreme Court granted an emergency appeal from Republicans on Friday, halting a lower-court ruling that would have limited cheaper broadcast ad rates to individual candidates only.
- The decision allows Republican party committees to access discounted TV ad rates ahead of the midterm elections, overturning a 4th Circuit Court of Appeals ruling favored by four Democratic candidates including Senator Jon Ossoff and former Senator Sherrod Brown.
- Justice Ketanji Brown Jackson was the sole public dissenter, arguing the court did not need to wait for an internal FCC review before acting.
- The ruling comes after a June Supreme Court decision that removed limits on party spending coordinated with candidates, which was seen as advantageous to Republicans due to their larger cash reserves.
The Supreme Court granted an emergency appeal from Republicans on Friday in a dispute over campaign ad pricing, temporarily halting a lower-court ruling that would have restricted discounted broadcast ad rates to individual candidates. The decision clears a legal path for Republican party committees to access cheaper TV advertising time ahead of the midterm elections.
Four Democratic candidates, including Senator Jon Ossoff of Georgia and former Senator Sherrod Brown of Ohio, had challenged an FCC Media Bureau finding from March that allowed party-coordinated ads to receive discounted rates. They won support from a divided panel of the U.S. 4th Circuit Court of Appeals, but the National Republican Congressional Committee and National Republican Senatorial Committee appealed to the Supreme Court, arguing that broadcasters were already charging them higher rates and disrupting their campaign budgets.
The Supreme Court majority agreed that the lower court had acted prematurely, stating that the higher ad rates would hamper Republican efforts to reach voters in the critical weeks before the midterms. Justice Ketanji Brown Jackson dissented, arguing the court could have proceeded without waiting for an internal FCC review. The decision halts the appeals court ruling while the Republican committees file a fuller appeal.
最高法院批准共和党关于中期选举前电视广告费率的紧急上诉
最高法院周五批准了共和党关于竞选广告定价的紧急上诉,暂时停止了一项下级法院的裁定,该裁定原本将折扣广播广告费率限制仅供个人候选人使用。该决定为共和党委员会在中期选举前获得廉价电视广告时段扫清了法律障碍。
包括乔治亚州参议员乔恩·奥索夫和俄亥俄州前参议员谢罗德·布朗在内的四名民主党候选人曾对联邦通信委员会媒体局3月份的一项裁定提出质疑,该裁定允许党派协调的广告获得折扣费率。他们获得了美国第四巡回上诉法院一个分裂法庭的支持,但全国共和党众议院委员会和全国共和党参议院委员会向最高法院上诉,辩称广播公司已经向他们收取更高费率,并破坏了他们的竞选预算。
最高法院多数派同意下级法院行动过于仓促,声称更高的广告费率将阻碍共和党在中期选举前关键几周内接触选民的努力。大法官凯坦吉·布朗·杰克逊表示反对,认为法院可以在不等待联邦通信委员会内部审查的情况下进行。该决定暂停了上诉法院的裁定,同时共和党委员会提交更完整的上诉。