Supreme Court grants Republican emergency appeal on TV ad rates before midterms
- The Supreme Court granted an emergency appeal from Republicans on Friday, halting a lower-court ruling that would have limited cheaper broadcast ad rates to candidates only.
- The decision allows political parties to access discounted TV ad time ahead of the November midterm elections, overturning a 4th Circuit Court of Appeals ruling favored by four Democratic candidates including Sen. Jon Ossoff and former Sen. Sherrod Brown.
- Justice Ketanji Brown Jackson was the sole public dissenter, arguing the court did not need to wait for an internal FCC review before acting.
- The Supreme Court's June ruling had already removed limits on party spending coordinated with candidates, and this decision on ad rates is seen as potentially advantageous to Republicans who have greater national party fundraising.
The Supreme Court granted an emergency appeal from Republicans on Friday in a dispute over campaign television ad pricing, temporarily halting a lower-court ruling that would have restricted discounted broadcast rates to candidates only. The decision clears the way for political parties to access cheaper TV ad time ahead of the November midterm elections.
Four Democratic candidates, including Senator Jon Ossoff of Georgia and former Senator Sherrod Brown of Ohio, had challenged the Federal Communications Commission's March decision allowing party-coordinated ads to receive discounted rates. They won support from a divided panel of the U.S. 4th Circuit Court of Appeals, but the Supreme Court majority determined the lower court had acted prematurely compared to rulings in other jurisdictions.
The National Republican Congressional Committee and National Republican Senatorial Committee argued that broadcasters had already begun charging them higher rates following the appeals court decision, disrupting their advertising budgets. Justice Ketanji Brown Jackson was the sole public dissenter, contending the Court did not need to await completion of an internal FCC review. The decision halts the appeals court ruling while the Republican committees pursue a fuller appeal.
最高法院批准共和党关于中期选举前电视广告费率的紧急上诉
最高法院周五批准了共和党关于竞选电视广告定价的紧急上诉,暂时停止了下级法院的裁决。该裁决原本将折扣广播费率仅限于候选人使用。该决定为政治党派在11月中期选举前获得廉价电视广告时段扫清了道路。
包括乔治亚州参议员奥索夫和俄亥俄州前参议员布朗在内的四名民主党候选人曾对美国联邦通信委员会3月份允许党派协调广告获得折扣费率的决定提出质疑。他们获得了美国第四巡回上诉法院分裂小组的支持,但最高法院多数意见认为下级法院的行动相比其他司法管辖区的裁决过于仓促。
全国共和党众议院委员会和全国共和党参议院委员会辩称,在上诉法院做出决定后,广播公司已开始向其收取更高费率,这扰乱了他们的广告预算。大法官凯坦吉·布朗·杰克逊是唯一公开反对者,她主张法院无需等待美国联邦通信委员会内部审查完成。该决定暂停了上诉法院的裁决,同时共和党委员会继续进行更全面的上诉。